Tag Archive: Gilad Shalit

Dealing with the reality of the Shalit deal and Hannibal Protocol:

Dr. Aaron Lerner Date: 19 October 2011

I received a lot of angry mail when I wrote earlier in the week that thanks to the very lopsided prisoner swaps, the IDF policy today is to do everything possible to kill IDF soldiers who appear to be in the process of being captured by terrorists.  Many couldn’t believe that this was indeed the policy of the IDF.  So I put up a video on YouTube of a Battalion 51 commander briefing his Golani troops on the eve of their entry into Gaza during Operation Cast Lead.


“The strategic weapon, the ‘Judgment Day Weapon’ that Hamas wants to acquire, is to capture a soldier. But no soldier in Battalion 51 will be kidnapped at any price. At any price. Under any condition. Even if it means that he blows himself with his own grenade together with those trying to capture him. Also even if it means that now his unit has to fire a barrage at the car that they are trying to take him away in. There is no situation. No situation that they will have this weapon.”

This was not some faked video. I copied from a video report broadcast on Israel Television Channel 2 News 16 October 2011

You can see the full report for yourself:


Now what does this all mean?  Am I saying that the Hannibal Protocol is wrong?  No. Not under the circumstances.  All I am saying is that we have to address the decisions we make with mature honesty.  The reason that we trade a thousand terrorists for a single soldier is not because of our commitment to do everything in our power to get our soldiers back home alive.  We do it because, as indicated by the polls, we don’t have the stomach to see soldiers as POWs once we know who they are. And since a key element of the equation is that this feeling only goes into play when we see their name, faces, etc., we as a society have a very different attitude about soldiers being killed before we see their name, faces, etc. And that is why we would rather kill a soldier being taken captive then have him sit somewhere being held by terrorists.

That is where we are.

And we have to deal with it.

Dr. Aaron Lerner, Director IMRA (Independent Media Review & Analysis) (Mail POB 982 Kfar Sava) Tel 972-9-7604719/Fax 972-3-7255730 INTERNET ADDRESS: imra@netvision.net.il

Website: http://www.imra.org.il

Shira’s note: Does this mean I’m indifferent, apathetic? It’s very conflicting for me. No, I am not that in my soul. If we understand acts of war and the knowledge that any goodness we have to fight evil is futile in a war of existentialism, then the above applies to us all whether we acknowledge it or not. We as a people have to sacrifice for the good in humanity. As such, if I’m to put myself in that position, as a soldier in the IDF, and if Gd willed, yes, I would be sacrificed for the people, namely, the children of Israel. So it is, if that is what is willed from on High. Reality is what it is…there are no words, actions, or opinions that would deter us from the truth, of which many try to oppress or try to prevaricate, in which the entire of humanity, governments, groups, or religions do to hide from their hypocrisies.


Jerusalem, 15 December 2010

Briefing on Israeli Policy Towards Palestinian Population In Judea, Samaria
& Gaza (Tue., 14 Dec. 2010)
(Communicated by the Public Diplomacy and Diaspora Affairs Media Advisor)

Public Diplomacy & Diaspora Affairs Minister Yuli Edelstein & Coordinator of
Govt. Activities in the Territories Maj.-Gen. Eitan Dangot yesterday (Tue.),
14.12.10, held a briefing on current Israeli policy towards the Palestinian
population in Judea, Samaria & Gaza.

Maj.-Gen Dagnot noted that while Israel is increasing its efforts to improve
the situation of the Palestinian population in Gaza, Israel must do so
without compromising its own security, and the safety of its civilian

These efforts include measures to increase movement of goods as much as
possible and encourage the proliferation of humanitarian projects
coordinated both with the PA and int’l organizations and governments.

Maj.-Gen Dagnot reminded that, paradoxically, during this same period of
efforts on the part of Israel to improve the situation of the Gazan
population, more than 20 rockets and mortars have been fired from Gaza at
the Kerem Shalom crossing point.  Israel pointedly is trying to
differentiate between its humanitarian measures to promote the wellbeing of
the Gazan civilian population, while battling Hamas that does not accord to
the conditions set by the Int’l Quartet and vehemently refuses to even
recognize the State of Israel‘s right to exit.

Minister Edelstein expressed his wish and the intentions of the Israel
Government to help the situation of Gazans, and Palestinians as a whole.
Replying to queries regarding Palestinian rights including freedom of
movement, the Minister said, “We would equally like to see those same
freedoms, accorded to kidnapped soldier Gilad Shalit.”

ER/al, ms                                               12:00 hours

IMRA – Independent Media Review and Analysis
Website: www.imra.org.il

Shira’s note:  This is to be read with the intention of sharing what news there really is and how leftist media decide not to acknowledge what really goes on in Israel and the ‘disputed’ territory.  They are not occupiers in their own land.  Israel does what it can humanitarian-wise and are not the oppressors.